Losing Judgment: Mexico's Judicial Reform

This 28-minute documentary film explains how Mexico's judicial reform dismissed approximately 7,000 judges and replaced merit-based judicial appointments with popular elections as the new system for selecting judges.

Through archival footage of Mexican government officials and firsthand testimony from judges, Supreme Court justices, journalists, lawyers, and regional and international experts, the film traces the origins of the reform and how it culminated in the country's first popular-vote election of judges in 2025, weakening the independence of the judiciary.

Learn More

Go deeper to learn about the history of judicial reform in Mexico and hear from the people who lived it (En español).

Image from website of the documentary film

Visit the Website

Visit the documentary's website to hear more about the origins of Mexico's judicial reform and the movement to stop the reforms.

Hear Judge Emilia Molina's story

Hear Judges' Stories

Hear the stories of judges who fought for judicial independence and experienced firsthand the impacts of the judicial reform.

Podcast recording about judicial reform documentary

Listen to the Podcast

Listen to legal experts and former judges discuss the judicial reform's impact in Mexico today. 

Credits

Date Released: September 18, 2026
Produced by: The Rule of Law Lab at NYU Law, Juicio Justo, and Konrad Adenauer Mexico
Director: Amir Galván Cervera, Réplica Films