Clinics

Family Defense Clinic with NY Defenders

LW.11540 / LW.10251
Professor Martin Guggenheim
Professor Christine Gottlieb
Open to 3L and 2L students
Maximum of 12 law students
Spring semester
7 credits*
No prerequisites or co-requisites.**

Introduction

Over the past generation, the number of children placed in foster care in the United States reached historical highs (comparable in some respects to the rising incarceration rate). At times, of course, it is appropriate to separate children from their families. The trend, however, has been to increase the ease with which state officials can take children into custody when they have concern about the children’s well-being, a determination that is highly subjective. The Family Defense Clinic has helped spearhead a movement–in New York City and nationally–over the past 20 years to push back against this trend. We believe that poor families, and poor families of color in particular, are entitled to the identical protections against unwelcome state intervention that wealthy parents (and their children) enjoy. The overwhelming majority of families that are monitored and disrupted by child welfare authorities are poor and they are disproportionately minorities. (In New York City, approximately 96 percent of the children in foster care are minorities.) The Family Defense Clinic strives to protect and expand the due process rights of these families, and to advocate for the services to which they are entitled, but which they are often denied. Central to the Clinic’s mission is to work through both direct representation and systemic advocacy to combat the indignity and inequality routinely experienced by parents involved with the child welfare system.

Clinic students participate in a semester-long, 7-credit course that examines child welfare policy and practice. The clinic's primary focus is on preventing the unnecessary break-up of indigent families and assisting separated families to reunite by representing individual parents and relatives of children who are in or at risk of foster care placement. The clinic also undertakes projects designed to address systemic problems in the foster care and Family Court systems. The clinic involves a mixture of fieldwork, seminar meetings, and participation in simulated exercises and hearings.

Course Description

Fieldwork

(a) The heart of the clinic is the opportunity to work on cases as counsel for parents in or at risk of entering foster care in Family Court with lawyers from premier defender offices in New York City. The cases include child neglect and abuse cases, termination of parental rights proceedings, and permanency planning hearings.

Students will work closely with defender offices in all phases of the representation. The fieldwork includes extensive client contact, interviewing, counseling, investigation, legal research, motion practice, discovery, out-of-court advocacy, and preparing for and conducting trials and dispositional hearings in Family Court. It is common for students to argue motions and conduct contested hearings before Family Court judges.

(b) Clinic students may also work with faculty on projects designed to improve child welfare policy and practice. The Clinic’s past projects have included legislative and regulatory lobbying; helping organize the first national association of parents advocates; drafting an amicus brief to the United States Supreme Court; preparing policy memoranda for the New York City Commissioner of Children’s Services; hosting conferences of institutional providers of legal representation for parents; designing and conducting a survey of parents whose children are in foster care; drafting a report on Family Court for the New York City Bar Association; and developing "know your rights" trainings for parents. In addition, the Clinic works with various defender services to litigate appeals aimed at developing significant case law in the field. Students may have the opportunity to participate in strategic appeal planning and to draft appellate briefs.

The Seminar

The seminar will generally meet twice each week for two hours. The early part of the semester will be devoted to study of the foster care system and the laws governing child protection and involuntary termination of parental rights. The seminar will focus on the cases students are handling, as well as broad policy questions in this field. Simulation exercises will focus on litigation skills, including interviewing, developing a theory of the case, direct and cross examination, and oral argument. The seminar will be used to discuss issues relating to race, class and gender in child welfare policy and practice, and ethical and systemic issues that arise in students' cases.

Application Procedure

Students should submit an application, resume and a transcript online via CAMS. Applicants will be contacted by Yvette Bisono for an interview with Martin Guggenheim or Christine Gottlieb. If you have any questions, you may contact Ms. Bisono at (212) 998-6177 or by email.

Students who enroll in the Family Defense Clinic as 2Ls may have the opportunity to join the Advanced Family Defense Clinic in their 3L year. There is no formal application process for the Advanced Family Defense Clinic. Students will be invited to apply in the spring for the following year.

Student Contacts

Students are encouraged to speak with current members of the clinic. The following law students are members of the 2015-16 clinic:

Hugh Baran
Emma Dinkelspiel
Jesus Franco
Lizz Harrington
Iris Hsiao
Jacob Hutt

Colin Mattis
Jess Moldovan
Julia Popkin
Elaine Saly
Sophie Spiegel
Ke Wu

Students should also feel free to contact Professors Martin Guggenheim and Christine Gottlieb if they have any questions or wish additional information. Marty can be reached at (212) 998-6460 and guggenh@exchange.law.nyu.edu. Chris can be reached at (212) 998-6693 and gottlieb@exchange.law.nyu.edu.


* 7 credits include 3 clinical credits and 4 academic seminar credits.

** Evidence is preferred but is not a prerequisite.